First of all, I would like to welcome everyone who has visited my blog via deadspin.com. I really appreciate all the new readers. Please feel free to chime inn whenever you have anything interesting to share with the Gavel Chat nation.



Here’s a humorous eBay auction you guys need to check out… CLICK HERE
I guess it probably isn’t too humorous for the poor guy who is getting taken to the cleaners by his ex-girlfriend however.
This girl supposedly got a hold of all this dude’s card, including some nice PSA rookies and vintage baseball cards, from the looks of the scans.
For crumps sakes… these kids weren’t married. The girl isn’t really entitled to any of the guy’s property. Isn’t this called stealing??? Hmm.


Check out the list of all these Chris Benoit items currently for sale on the Bay… More than 1500 pieces are being sold and these people are obviously taking advantage of the disturbed wrestler’s death. This raises an important question. Should sellers not be selling Benoit items out of respect for his family, or do you guys say it doesn’t really matter.
Honestly, I am torn on this subject, but would love to hear your thoughts.

Gonna be a quick blog today, as I have been working on a number of stories and one breaking story, which I will be publishing tomorrow (trust me, you won't wanna miss this one).

Today I received the initial list of the items that will be featured in Mastro's live auction at The National. Some very nice pieces, including Mickey Mantle's 500th home run ball and a T206 Honus Wagner.
Here are some of the items:

 Mid 70s Pistol Pete Maravich Jazz game-used jersey
 1970 Topps Pete Maravich PSA 10
 1921-23 Babe Ruth game-used bat
 1907-08 Ty Cobb game-used bat
 Rookie era DiMaggio game-used bat
 "Momen" Clemente Rookie-era game-used bat
 1910 T215 Pirates Tobacco near set
 T206 Honus Wagner
 1950 Toleteros Josh Gibson
 1914 Boston Garter Joe Jackson
 1933 Nap Lajoie
 Mickey Mantle 500th home run ball
 1915 contract for Rupert's purchase of Yankees
 Casey Sengel's 1958 World Series ring
 Barry Bond #70 home run ball
 Christy Mathewson single-singed ball
 Early 80's Gretzky jersey
 1969 game-worn Hank Aaron jersey

The event will be held Aug. 3 at the House of Blues in Cleveland. I just booked my flight and will be reporting from the event. Can't wait to go to the convention center with the big ferris wheel in the middle of the building.

Seriously, you'll want to check out my blog tomorrow, as I will be interviewing a very interesting former Major League ball player tomorrow afternoon.

In the past couple months I have participated in quite a few auctions. I have bought things and sold things, and definitely have lost out on MANY things.

In the past couple weeks I have both won items and sold items, and in both cases, am left asking a couple questions.

Now, I am not going to name names, mainly because I feel that it is any business’ right to charge whatever it wishes, but I also have the right as a customer to stop doing business with anybody I choose. (It hasn't come to that yet, but it might some day soon)

For my first question, I will indirectly ask the auction house who charged me a $60 processing fee to sell my items, why they feel the need to charge me this fee?

I understand that there are many costs into producing an auction, but why wouldn’t the company just incorporate all fees in the sellers’ fee?

As if the 15 and 20 percent it took from the final sale price wasn’t bad enough, the company also charged me this extra chunk of change.

Not a big deal, but seemed kind of petty to me.

On the buyer side I also have a question to a different auction house. I bought a nice signed book about a month ago. If I were to ship an item like this it cost me about five bucks. I understand that the workers at the auction have to pick the item out of inventory and that costs money, but I was charged $15 for shipping and an additional $10 service charge. I just about dropped out of my chair.

Anyway, all this isn’t that big of a deal. In fact, all this didn’t stop me from bidding in Mastro’s sale that ended last night. I even was fortunate enough to win the pictured Babe Ruth Called Shot ticket stub.

Happy hunting folks. Have a great weekend!

The obvious answer is no. Sammy Sosa hit his 600th career home run last night and nobody seems to be talking about what it would sell for in auction. From what I understand, the ball actually made its way into the Rangers’ bullpen, so it may never end up being sold publicly. I just wonder if anybody would give this the hype that a ball of this historic magnitude would presumably deserve, or if it is just another piece of Sosa’s rather-sad history.

We may never find out. Maybe the better question is “Will he make the Hall of Fame?” Thoughts?

*********************

Tonight Mastro, American Memorabilia and Premier Auctions are all closing.

Not to change the subject, but a Mastro representative called me today about its live event that is going to take place at The National in Cleveland August 3. According to the representative, Mastro will be offering some of the best material they ever have, including Mickey Mantle’s 500th home run ball. Talk about a museum piece!

I am currently trying to get a complete list of items that will be featured in its auction. Stay tuned.

Last night I had a bunch of auctions that ended on eBay. I didn’t sell anything spectacular, just some odds and ends like some Packers signed prints from the 60s. The first person who paid for one of the items sent payment via Paypal.

Now, I normally don’t have a problem accepting Paypal payments, but this guy sent it in the form that it takes like 3-5 days to clear (a pending payment).

I am not a big fan of going to the post office, so whenever this happens, it turns into a bit of a hassle. I like to send all the items at once.

Another thing that really irks me is when it takes some winning bidders a week or two to pay for an item they win from me on eBay. What’s worse is when they take two weeks to pay and then give me the business if I take a couple extra days to send out their item.

I think if a person takes ten days to send payment for an item, then that should give the seller the right to take ten days to send the item.

Breath deep Chris… Ok… I feel better. Sorry for the rant guys, but now I feel better:)

This crazy sale, features one of the weirdest items I have ever seen and it can be yours for a cool 65K. You will get an autographed photo and the all-important FINGER NAIL CLIPPINGS of Muhammad Ali! Yep, this is an eBay first for me.

****************************

I recently was asked, via the Tuff Stuff message boards, a question about Brett Favre autographed photos and what they are currently selling for. I told the person my estimate and where he could go to find a legit Favre sig… I also said that he could probably go to eBay and get a better price, but that he would have to be careful because of all the fakes that make their way to the Bay.
After I posted this I figured I would take a gander at what the Favre autograph situation actually was on eBay.

To my astonishment, I must say that there are an awful lot of horrible fake Favre autographs currently on eBay.

I am no expert on signatures, but a lot of these are not even close. Plus, the fact that some are selling for under $20 is a big red flag.

Very sad that some people are getting ripped off by these worthless crooks. Part of the problem is the customer though. If you see a Jordan signature on eBay for $50, it is a fake.
If there is a Mantle signature on eBay for $100, it is a fake.

And if you see a Favre signature on eBay for only $15, it is a fake.
Come on people. If the price is too good to be true, it is usually a FAKE!

In about one hour I will be on the road to Illinois, where I will attend Sportsfest.

I am hoping to meet a lot of the readers and dealers that I never had the chance to meet, and also hope to find some unique Packer items while I'm there.

You never know what might turn up, but at the very least I will get to check out some of the hobby's greatest cards and memorabilia.

I'm sure I will have some stories to tell on Monday, so check out Gavel Chat next week. Hope to see you at the show!

Ok, nobody really expects the Cavs to defeat the Spurs in the Finals this year, but if somehow the unimaginable happens, and the Lebron-led Cleveland squad beats the crafty San Antonio Spurs, Lebron James may propel himself into the category of best player in the NBA and eventually may even be considered better than Michael Jordan.

I know that this is a stretch, but Lebron has already brought his team to the Finals and he’s only 22 years old.

Lebron doesn’t have much more talent on his team than Kobe has on the Lakers and the Cavs look much more impressive than the Lake Show.

I know, I know… The Lakers are in the West. Big deal. Even if the Lakers were in the Eastern Conference I highly doubt that they would be in the Finals and no matter what, you have to admit that Lebron has handled himself much better than Kobe has and King James is about six years younger.
It seems like just yesterday James was placed on the cover of SI as a high schooler when he instantly became a household name. Now he is competing for the NBA’s top prize. Simply amazing.

The last card show I attended was the 2006 National in Anaheim. I think I was there for only one day, so I really didn’t get my fill. I am a memorabilia junkie. Going to card shows is one of my favorite parts of this job.
Where else can you see all those great cards and pieces of memorabilia under the same roof?
All the big-time dealers will be in attendance at this year’s SportsFest. I have been to almost every SportsFest since its origin and I am excited to check out its new location in Schaumburg, Illinois.


Now something really off-topic… I finally am going to join the 21st Century and buy an LCD flat-screen TV.
For those of you who don’t know, Krause Publications is in a very small town in Wisconsin and there isn’t a whole lot to do during the weekdays. That said, I spend more time than I should watching television. May as well do it in style.
In the next few weeks I will be making the purchase. If anyone has any flat-screen TV advice, please let me know. One of my friends told me that LCD is much better than Plasma. Does anyone have any thoughts on this? I can’t wait to watch NFL football on a nice tv!

For the past few years, various publications, online news outlets and Internet message boards have been talking about game-worn jersey and autograph authenticators and their roles within an auction house operation.

Much of this coverage has become very heated and sometimes even controversial.
It’s understandable. Hundreds and sometimes thousands of dollars are at stake and anyone that has, or feels they have a potential of getting burnt when spending their hard-earned money will feel very strongly on this subject.

Now my take on all of this: There was a time when auction houses didn’t even use authenticators, in fact, many mom and pop auction houses that deal with family estates don’t use an authenticator and have an “All Sales are Final” policy. As a general rule, auctions are not like Wal-Mart… You usually are expected to pay for the item as an “as-is” type situation. At least that’s how it used to be.

Many of the people who own auction houses may have some knowledge in the area of sports memorabilia that they are selling, but very few can be classified as “experts.” That is why third-party authenticators are brought in to go through the auction items and offer their opinion on each lot.

I just had the opportunity to buy a nice vintage Packers jersey that may have been game-worn. It took me about a week of phone calls and my own research to determine that it was not a gamer.
A week!

Many auctions hire authenticators for only a couple days and they are expected to go through hundreds of pieces.

In my opinion, there is no way that this can be done in this amount of time without making any mistakes.
Also, keep in mind... authenticators DO reject many jerseys that were consigned for a particular auction. I remember Lou Lampson rejecting over 50 jerseys for one American Memorabilia sale, when I still worked there. There was never any intent to deceive a customer into buying a jersey that we didn't think was game-worn.

Now, I know some of you will say that the authenticators should be brought in for a longer period of time… That sounds like a good idea, in theory, but it isn’t that realistic. First of all, that costs much more money for the auction house and second of all, there are deadlines to get the catalogs prepared.

That said, this time constraint should not let the auction house off the hook if a mistake is made. “All sales final” policy or not, if a mistake is made on a jersey and it is called to the auction houses’ attention, in my opinion the business should stand behind its item.

That can also sometimes be tough though. Many times a consignor is already paid when a problem surfaces and as a result that money can not be gotten back easily. Maybe have a 10-day return policy or something.

Anyway, that’s my take… I asked Troy Kinunen of MEARS to chime in on this topic and here is what he provided me:

For his blog, Gavel Chat, Chris Nerat asked me to give my views on how
authenticators are treated on various message boards. With my
association with MEARS as a person who gives opinions, I know what it is
like to be on the receiving end of message board created criticism.

As an organization, MEARS always separated the sometimes-personal natures of the criticism and examined what the core of the issues was. In the early
years of the internet, topics such as undisclosed conflict of interest,
proper attribution of authenticator to work, creation of terms and
definitions, and responsibility of authenticator to their opinions were
often the topic of debate.

Therefore, the message boards served as a voice to our organization where
concerns were stated and for which current policies were shaped and
in-acted. To date, in response to hobby concerns, MEARS was the first
authentication company to voluntarily disclose which lots members of our
company owned when consigning to various auction houses. Both Dave Bushing
and myself volunteered to have our names listed in the auction house
descriptions and Rob Lifson of REA was the first to incorporate the
practice. When we were not listed in the actual lot description, the lots
were identified on the MEARS homepage, and were in an area that was open to
any interested parties. This change was the result of concerns voiced on
various internet forums.

We have expanded on the policy and with the launch of the MEARS For Sale
site, at the top of each description the owner of the item is identified.

The topic of responsibility of an authenticator to their opinions is the most often voiced concern for collectors. MEARS takes this responsibility
seriously. I am quite aware of the amount of work it takes to get an authentication of an item correct.
For the year 2007, MEARS was only contracted with Mastro Auctions and REA. The contract called for us to look at all game worn/used items submitted to those houses. With our long-standing policy, a grade is assigned to each and every bat and jersey we offer opinions on. This included both favorable opinions and items deemed unable to authenticate.
Over a 50-week calendar year, we schedule a minimum of 56 hours per week to authentication per those two auction contracts alone. It typically takes 6 weeks per Mastro Auction and about 46 weeks for REA. The rest of our staff handles photography, letter production, data entry, website maintenance, reference material archiving, and retail submissions.
We have mandated for our auction house contracts that all our grades, which sometimes are low and not favorable, are printed in the lot description of their catalogs.
Another policy invoked by MEARS to address the concerns of accountability to collectors is our practice of writing letters on 100% of the items that we inspect. This means even the bats and jerseys that we reject. Those are
titled as "unable to authenticate."
Those items are hologramed, photographed, a worksheet is completed, and the opinion is archived in both the LOO and trade index portion of our website, which is available for members. The member's section is part of our $40.00 subscription fee, but the fee charged is used to offset the labor fees of producing the LOO‚s and maintaining them on our website.

Chat rooms and forums will continue to facilitate discussions with respect
to the opinions offered by authenticators. This is a good thing, as each
group of authenticators will continue to be responsible for the opinions
offered. Criticism will still be given when collectors feel a wrong opinion
has been given. But, what I have noticed, is there is nowhere near as much
credit given when somebody does a good job. Take a moment to thank an auction house that does do things right. I can't speak for non-contract
holders, but when we are contracted to for a calendar year to offer
opinions, the cost is substantial to the auction house. By hiring MEARS,
profits have been lessened, as contract holders are willing to pay for the
services provided by our company.
Chat rooms are here to stay, so lets continue to use them in a manner that enlightens the collectors and creates continued excellence from the
authenticators whom understand their responsibilities.

Sincerely,


Troy R. Kinunen
MEARS

Hopefully my opinions and what Troy touched on will spark some discussion. You can post your comments to this blog or email me at chris.nerat@fwpubs.com

I am still putting together my blog dealing with the way authenticators are treated, so I will hold off on writing it for a few more days.

Today I want to focus on the Mastro catalog that I received in the mail today. It came poly-bagged and included a magazine put out by SGC, and to my surprise, a DVD about The Lionel Carter Collection.

If you haven’t heard yet, Carter is a true baseball card pioneer and this year he decided to sell his collection through Mastro Auctions.

I just finished watching the video and I must say that I am very impressed. The 30-minute DVD was one of the most informative programs covering the hobby that I have ever seen.

The video includes interviews from Bill Mastro, Doug Allen, Lionel Carter and others.

The great thing about the program is that you get to see Doug and Lionel going through the collection. Video allows the viewer to experience much more than a photograph could provide.
I think in the future you will see many more auction houses utilizing more video, at least I hope so. I would have paid money for this DVD and it actually came free with Mastro’s catalog.